“Paul was so attentive, professional, patient and compassionate throughout the whole selling and buying process. Our selling process was uniquely challenging, and he and Jill were always available in some way, shape or form for questions and answers, and they were always ready and willing to solve any problem that arose. He was able to keep us calm and sober in our most anxious moments. We would definitely recommend him without hesitation. Paul Gunder is first class.”

Ken and Angala Nelson

“Paul was great to work with during the process of selling my home. He is very knowledgeable and answered all my questions. He kept me informed and up to date the entire time. He went above and beyond my expectations. I would highly recommend him and will be contacting him for all my future real estate needs.”

Jillian Lininger

“Paul was very patient and attentive, and he provided us with very good advice about what we, as sellers, needed to do to increase interest in our home. We greatly appreciated the time he spent with us, the knowledge he shared with us and how thorough he was with coordinating all the moving parts of the closing process once we had a buyer. I will recommend him highly to anyone who is starting the process of selling and/or buying a home.”

Charles Dawson

“Paul was very helpful, going beyond call of duty in selling our property through an estate sale. He was always calm and there for us when assistance was needed or when questions needed answers. From first showings (two on the first day on the market) until settlement was six weeks total. Could not asked for better agent.”

Jack Scott

“Shout out to Paul Gunder for working tirelessly over the past 20 months to finalize the sale of our lot. We have been trying to sell our lot for years, and Paul gave us more potential buyers than we had in the previous eight-plus years with other real estate firms. Hard work does make the difference.”

Marcia Wagner

“Paul made the process of selling my house extraordinarily easy. I live out of state, and Paul took care of everything so that I did not need to take any time off work and travel. Paul provided me with knowledgeable guidance on key decisions which, without following his advice, would have cost me more money. The house sold quicker than I expected. Both Paul and Jill were great with communication and very responsive. I highly recommend Paul Gunder to anyone looking to sell or buy!”

Tiffany Tresler

“We used Paul Gunder to list our home. He looked over the situation and gave us good advice on various things. We followed his advice, and the home did sell at the full asking price. Paul has lots of good experience and really looks after every little need. He’s easy to contact via various methods and always responds to a request quickly. Every detail was handled properly and promptly. We had no worries at all. We recommend Paul 100%. He’s very responsible and pleasant to work with.”

Stan Besecker

“I received outstanding service and support in selling a property that I have owned for 15 years from Paul Gunder and Coldwell Banker Realty. It was one of the best decisions to seek Paul’s professional advice. He had been highly recommended by several friends in Waynesboro after I expressed disappointment with several other agencies that I had worked with in the past. Paul and his colleague Jill made the whole process go smoothly every step of the way, from getting the property listed to its settlement. Paul’s professional, kind and thoughtful demeanor is what everyone would want when dealing with such an important life event. I am a very satisfied client!”

Paul Engelstad

“Paul is an exceptional, seasoned professional. Throughout the home buying process, Paul was responsive to all requests for information in a manner that provided facts and insights invaluable for timely decision-making. His understanding of market dynamics and detailed explanation of various options helped to assure informed decisions at multiple points in moving to close. Without doubt, he is a highly reliable and trustworthy professional.”

Ann Spottswood

“We recently moved to Gettysburg, and Paul helped us our purchase our new built home. Initially we weren’t sure we needed a realtor to purchase new construction, but Paul’s insight and knowledge of the building industry and real estate transactions was invaluable. He was a pleasure to work with and we would highly recommend him.”

Ann Morton

“Our family was living in Maryland and decided to relocate to Pennsylvania. The process of selling our current house and buying a new home was a very positive experience with Paul Gunder. He was very responsive addressing our needs and answering our questions. I would highly recommend Paul when buying or selling a home.”

Beeler Caldwell

“Working with Paul Gunder, his team and Coldwell Banker Realty was exceptional. Having purchased homes in the past, this was by far the best experience we have had. The level of communications, customer care and personal follow up were second to none. We definitely made the right decision working with Paul. Six-star recommendation.”

Bruce Larson

“I was very pleased with the way Paul handled the sale of my parents’ home. He was very professional and knowledgeable. The house sold very quickly.”

Sandy Koons

“Paul Gunder has assisted me with several real estate transactions over the past 36 years. He has always provided good ideas and advice, communicates well, always follows through and makes sure everything is handled appropriately. It has always been without hesitation that I have called him for my real estate needs and recommend him to others.”


Rose Dagen

“Paul has been great to work with. So far, I have been able to purchase two properties with Paul’s help at very fair prices. He has always been responsive and professional, returning calls very quickly. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a property to work with Paul and his team.”

Cody G

“We just closed on selling our house today, and I have to say I couldn’t be happier. Paul and his team were with us every step of the way. I don’t think there is a more experienced Realtor in the Waynesboro area. I would recommend Paul Gunder to anyone buying or selling a home. His knowledge, patience and good humor made our experience a breeze.”

George Levick

“Paul and his staff went out of their way to help us in every way during the sale of our house and also with our new (to us) house. We would recommend them to everyone!”

Mark Blakely

Paul was informative and patient throughout the process. He helped my wife and I through the sale of our first home and it went seamlessly.
David Nixdorf

“I have to say Paul Gunder is the very best! I was purchasing a historic home, and we ran into many obstacles in the months and weeks leading up to the closing. Each time we had an issue, Paul worked with all parties to resolve the problem in his very calm and professional manner. Even after the closing when issues arose, he stepped up and figured out a way to work with the authorities or whomever it took to find the best possible solution. Paul goes above and beyond what is expected of any real estate agent, and I highly recommend him to work with you for your real estate needs.”

Alan Cohn

“Thank you, Paul, for making the sale of our house a great experience in the midst of a pandemic. You kept us informed and up to date on all details. I really appreciated your help in a couple of emergencies that happened, and you took charge and took care of them. We didn’t have to make a trip to PA to take care of them, which was really nice for us. You all were wonderful; thank you so much.”

Donna Gardner

“Paul and Emily were true professionals in selling our farm and the purchase of our new home. They were responsive to our needs and requests. Emily hand-carried documents to our place of business as well as our residence. Our farm had been on the market off and on with various agents for over five years, but Paul persevered and ended up putting that SOLD sign in the yard we long awaited to see. He is definitely the agent we prayed for and can’t express our gratitude enough!”

Janet Wagaman

“I would like to say thank you to Paul Gunder for all the help you gave us when we listed our home with you. We were in Florida, and Paul watched our home like it was his. He always answered his phone, if he couldn’t return my call promptly. He made us feel at ease with the whole process. We put our home up for sale at about the same time that COVID-19 hit. The closing wasn’t a normal closing due to COVID. We couldn’t all meet; it had to be done separately, seller then buyer. Paul kept us up to date on all information and how it was going to take place. I really can’t say enough about Paul Gunder. Great job you guys – thank you for everything.”

Donna Gardner

“The process and experience with listing to settlement with Mr. Gunder and his team at Coldwell Banker Realty was effortless on our part. Very professional, effective and responsive to all our needs. I would highly recommend Paul to anyone when selling or purchasing a home.”

Ed Flynn

“Paul has professionally completed four distinct real estate transactions for me over the past 27 years, from 1991 to 2018. I will tell you definitively, I would not have continued using Paul’s professional knowledge and experience if I were not fully satisfied each step of the way.”

Todd Sheldon

“Thank you, Paul, for being a thorough and thoughtful realtor. You have facilitated three real estate transactions for us, and we look forward to many more in the future. You and Jill are a pleasure to work with.”

Mark D

“Paul was so helpful in the sale of our home. Made the process so easy. Highly recommend.”

Constance Walter

“Buying and selling a home during COVID-19 wasn’t easy. Paul did an exceptional job during this time. He is very helpful, friendly, knowledgeable and dependable! I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor!”

Markham Grimes III

“Paul was great to work with and very professional. I highly recommend his services.”

Mike Yingling

Paul worked with my mom to sell our family home of over 44 years. He went out of his way to guide us with house prep information/ realistic advice and used his extensive network to move work and ultimately the sale of the home forward quickly. Highly recommend!

Katie Gaulding

“Paul is a great professional realtor. We will call on him again.”

Frank Damazo

We called Paul, from out of state, to see a property he had listed in Waynesboro. It was wonderful to work with someone so professional and knowledgeable. Having lived here all his life, Paul was able to answer all our questions about the community, as well as the home we were looking at with him. His reach in the community includes knowing contractors, the arts community, the medical system and even where to shop!! He was quick to respond to calls/emails/texts and was willing to do what ever we needed to help us make the right choice for us. This included recommending a great place to stay the night, with a sweet discount. We have dealt with quite a number and variety of real estate professionals during this year long process and Paul surpassed them all in terms of both quality and service. I would highly recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy a home!


Bill Schellhardt

I worked with Paul to sell our home. He was wonderful to work with…provided guidance and suggestions on what changes were needed and always available for any questions. The home sold in 5 days. It was a pleasure to work with someone so knowledgeable and attentive to his clients.

Debra Tutterice

Paul was extremely helpful in selling our home. He had a well thought out plan and it resulted in over a dozen showings in the first 3 days! He made the process quick and simple. We highly recommend him!

Elizabeth May

Outstanding service and communication during the entire selling process.

Greg McCleaf